Synapse Physiotherapy | Physio Center | Rehab Malaysia

dry needling vs acupuncture
Synapse Physiotherapy

Which is more effective, acupuncture or dry needling?

Inserting needles into the skin might sound unusual, but surprisingly, many individuals with injuries or painful conditions turn to this method as an alternative treatment for pain relief.

 

Dry needling and acupuncture are two popular therapies that involve piercing the skin with fine, stainless steel needles for healing purposes. Although both aim to alleviate pain, they differ significantly in their approach. At a glance, dry needling vs acupuncture may appear identical, as both use thin needles inserted into the skin and both claim to ease pain. However, one has roots in traditional Chinese medicine, dating back thousands of years, and has a solid body of research behind it, while the other has only been in use for a few decades.

 

Acupuncture works by stimulating the nervous system and releasing endorphins, whereas dry needling targets muscle knots and trigger points to release tension.

 

Finding the right treatment to manage your pain can be challenging, especially if you’re unsure of the underlying cause. Let’s explore the differences between dry needling and acupuncture to help you decide which might be the better option for you.

What is Dry Needling?

Dry needling is a contemporary treatment aimed at reducing muscle pain, and it has been gaining popularity. In a dry needling session, a practitioner inserts several fine, stainless steel filiform needles into the skin. These needles are not used to inject any substance, which is why the technique is referred to as “dry.” The needles are placed into “trigger points” within the muscle or tissue—areas of tight or hardened muscle. This method is sometimes called intramuscular stimulation. Practitioners believe that the needles help release muscle knots, alleviating pain and muscle spasms.

Technique

Dry needling involves inserting fine needles into muscle “trigger points” to relieve pain and tension. After identifying these tight spots, the practitioner inserts the needles into the muscle and may manipulate them by gently moving or twisting them. This manipulation is designed to elicit a local twitch response—an involuntary muscle contraction—that helps release the tension in the muscle. The twitch response improves blood flow and reduces pain, promoting relaxation of the tight muscle. The needles are left in for a few minutes before removal, and additional exercises may follow to enhance the treatment’s effect.

Post-event

Suppose you’re experiencing pain from an injury like a sprain, strain, or fracture. In that case, a physiotherapist can assist in your recovery after your doctor’s initial treatment by prescribing exercises and therapies that help restore your strength, flexibility, and range of motion. Additionally, if your injury resulted from a fall, a physiotherapist can work with you to enhance your balance and coordination, reducing the risk of future falls and further injury.

 

For instance, if you’ve recently fractured your ankle in a fall, a physiotherapist can create a personalized exercise program aimed at improving balance, proprioception, and coordination. Exercises such as standing on one leg, walking heel-to-toe, and practicing weight shifts can enhance your balance and decrease the likelihood of future falls. This is especially crucial for older adults, as falls often lead to injury, reduced mobility, and a lower quality of life.

 

If you suddenly experience severe pain, such as waking up with intense neck pain or suddenly developing severe lower back pain that disrupts your daily activities, work, or sleep, it’s advisable to seek prompt evaluation from a physiotherapist. They can assess your condition, recommend strategies to relieve your pain, and help you regain full function as swiftly as possible. Additionally, they may screen for any signs of serious underlying medical issues that could require further medical evaluation.

 

If your pain persists despite rest or over-the-counter medications, it’s important to consult a physiotherapist. They can identify the underlying cause of your pain and offer targeted treatment to relieve it.

 

For instance, Achilles tendon pain might improve with rest but could return when you resume activities like running. In such situations, a physiotherapist can develop a rehabilitation plan to address the issue and help prevent its recurrence.

Benefits

Alleviating Muscle Tightness and Pain: Dry needling effectively targets trigger points in the muscles, prompting them to contract and relax, which helps restore normal function and alleviate pain and tightness. Many patients experience immediate relief, with more significant benefits typically seen after several sessions.

 

Enhancing Range of Motion: By addressing muscle tension and trigger points, dry needling can improve or restore range of motion, leading to better overall function and decreased discomfort.

 

Speeding Up Recovery: For athletes and active individuals, dry needling can expedite the recovery process. It promotes muscle relaxation and increases blood circulation, providing vital oxygen and nutrients to the injured areas, which facilitates quicker healing.

Side effect

Mild side effects are common with dry needling, while serious complications are rare.

The most frequent side effects at the needle insertion site include:

  • Bruising
  • Minor bleeding
  • Temporary soreness

What is acupuncture?

Acupuncture involves the insertion of ultra-fine needles into specific points on the body. A fundamental aspect of traditional Chinese medicine, it is primarily used to alleviate pain but is increasingly recognized for its role in promoting overall wellness, including stress management.

 

According to traditional Chinese medicine, acupuncture aims to balance the flow of energy, or life force, known as chi or qi (chee), which is believed to travel through pathways called meridians in the body. By placing needles at precise points along these meridians, acupuncture practitioners aim to restore harmony to the energy flow.

Technique

Traditionally, acupuncture is based on the belief that illness arises from blocked or disrupted qi, which is the healing energy that sustains your body. The practice aims to eliminate these blockages and restore a balanced flow of energy.

 

Needle Insertion: Acupuncture needles are inserted at varying depths into specific points on your body. Due to their thinness, the insertion typically causes minimal discomfort, and many people do not feel the needles at all. A standard treatment usually involves 5 to 20 needles, and you might experience a mild aching sensation when a needle reaches the appropriate depth.

 

Needle Manipulation: After insertion, your practitioner may gently move or twist the needles or apply heat or mild electrical pulses to enhance the treatment’s effects.

 

Needle Removal: The needles are generally left in place for 10 to 15 minutes while you relax. Removal is usually painless and causes no discomfort.

Benefits

Pain Relief: Acupuncture is highly effective for alleviating both acute and chronic pain, commonly used for back pain, neck pain, osteoarthritis, migraines, and menstrual cramps. It works by reducing inflammation, triggering the release of endorphins, and adjusting the nervous system’s pain response.

 

Stress Reduction and Relaxation: Many find acupuncture sessions deeply calming. By targeting specific points, it helps regulate the body’s stress response, promoting relaxation and alleviating anxiety. Improved sleep quality is also frequently reported after treatment.

 

Mental Health: Acupuncture positively influences mood and mental wellness by balancing neurotransmitters like serotonin and dopamine. It is often used as a complementary therapy for conditions such as depression, anxiety, and PTSD.

 

Enhanced Immune Function: Acupuncture may boost the immune system by improving Qi flow and balancing internal systems. Regular sessions can strengthen the immune response and lower the risk of illness.

 

Better Digestive Health: Acupuncture can help regulate digestion and relieve gastrointestinal issues like IBS, acid reflux, bloating, and constipation. By enhancing energy flow and reducing stress, it may improve digestion and nutrient absorption.

 

Hormonal Balance: Acupuncture can help regulate hormonal imbalances, benefiting those with conditions like PCOS, infertility, menopausal symptoms, and irregular periods by normalizing cycles and alleviating hormonal fluctuations.

Side effect

Possible side effects may include bruising, bleeding, and a mild, achy sensation at the needle insertion site.

Which is better?

Now that you’re familiar with the benefits and risks of dry needling and acupuncture, you might wonder which one is the better treatment option. Surprisingly, it largely comes down to personal preference. If your goal is to alleviate muscle pain and tightness, dry needling could be a great choice. On the other hand, if you’re addressing a specific medical condition, acupuncture might be more suitable.

 

Both treatments can leave you feeling relaxed or energized, but individual responses may vary. If your symptoms don’t improve within a few weeks, it’s possible that neither, or only one of the treatments, may be effective for you. It’s important to note that dry needling and acupuncture are not substitutes for conventional medical treatments such as physiotherapy or surgery.

 

This is why consulting your healthcare provider and seeking out highly qualified practitioners is essential before trying either treatment.

 

You might want to consider trying dry needling services offered by a professional and certified physiotherapist, like those at Synapse Physiotherapy. Their expertise ensures that you receive safe and effective treatment tailored to your specific needs.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Most patients experience mild discomfort during the treatment, often described as a quick pinch or muscle twitch. This discomfort typically subsides immediately.

It depends on the severity of your condition. For most patients, 5–10 sessions yield noticeable improvements.

Yes, some practitioners use both methods together to address different aspects of pain and recovery.

Both dry needling and acupuncture are safe when performed by licensed and trained professionals. Always ensure your practitioner is certified.

Relief can vary. Some patients feel immediate improvement after dry needling, while acupuncture benefits often become noticeable after a few sessions.

Conclusion

Both acupuncture and dry needling are valuable treatments for pain relief and overall wellness. Dry needling focuses on addressing muscle-specific issues, making it ideal for athletes and individuals recovering from injuries. Acupuncture, with its holistic approach, is suitable for those seeking to manage chronic pain, stress, or other systemic conditions.

 

When considering which therapy is better, it ultimately depends on your unique needs. Consulting a healthcare professional is crucial to determine the most effective treatment plan. If you’re looking for a qualified practitioner, consider Synapse Physiotherapy, where experienced professionals offer personalized dry needling services designed to alleviate pain and restore function. Take the first step toward a healthier, pain-free life today!

Produced by MYSense

Share This :

Back & Neck Pain

Conditions such as stiffness, postural abnormalities and muscle overuse from prolonged desk work at the office or home is more prevalent than most would think. We provide the necessary tools to fix you up and educate you on ergonomics which can unload unnecessary stress.

Sports Injuries

Rolled ankles, jarred knees, impinged shoulders are few conditions in the plethora of sports injuries which can hamper performance and limit our enjoyment of sports. Physiotherapy not only treats the symptoms of these conditions but propels your overall fitness to greater heights.

Work Desk Injuries​

Conditions such as stiffness, postural abnormalities and muscle overuse from prolonged desk work at the office or home is more prevalent than most would think. We provide the necessary tools to fix you up and educate you on ergonomics which can unload unnecessary stress.

Pre-Post-Surgical Conditions

Surgery involves going through preparation both before and after. Physiotherapists play a vital role in getting your body ready for surgeries with circulatory, breathing and strengthening exercises. After the procedure, let us be there for your recovery and rehabilitation, taking it one step at a time.

Scoliosis & Postural Abnormalities

The way we stand, sit, walk and sleep has influence over our posture and the overall balance of muscles controlling its alignment. A comprehensive screening can be done by our physiotherapists to detect abnormalities, which we will aid in correcting.

Neurological Conditions

Neurological disabilities such as stroke, nerve compression and neuropathies can be barriers for patients to live life to its fullest. We at Synapse are committed to help you overcome these hurdles by ensuring functional mobility and quality of life is at its optimum by providing the right treatment and exercises.

Osteoarthritis & Rheumatism

Joint degeneration and inflammation happens as the human body grows older, but that does not mean our way of life degenerates as well. Relief your joint pains with a joint effort together with your physiotherapist, who will provide pain-relief treatments and prescribe exercises for your wellbeing.

Conditions Relating To Elderly

Common conditions in the older age population include hips & knee pain, back & neck pain, osteoarthritis, rheumatism, fear of falling and many more.  Aging and degeneration of bodily function is inevitable, but here at Synapse, we will help you live the best of your life.

Home Physiotherapy

We understand that some conditions or injuries can make it difficult to receive rehabilitation at our clinic be it mobility or transportation issues. Our objective is to provide you with the same high-quality physiotherapy services at home that you would receive in-clinic.